Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Book review: 'Even As We Breathe' delivers as debut novel for Cherokee author
Book Review

Book review: 'Even As We Breathe' delivers as debut novel for Cherokee author

  • Updated
  • Comments

Annette Saunooke Clapsaddle’s debut novel is a delight for so many reasons. For starters, it’s a good story, well told and a pleasure to read. That counts for a lot, but it’s only the beginning of what’s to be found in this deceptively slim book.

This richly layered book is, on one level, a historical novel, drawing on a real story that even many North Carolinians don’t know — that soon after the United States entered World War II, the storied Grove Park Inn in Asheville was used as a luxurious internment site for Axis diplomats and their families who were in this country and became prisoners.

As with the best historical fiction, this novel’s glimpses into the past also illuminate our present, particularly the way people who are considered “other” — in this case, Cherokee natives — in some way are subjected to inequities and indignities. Without preaching or intrusive exposition, Clapsaddle subtly connects the story she’s telling to larger ideas.

“Even As We Breathe” is also a coming-of-age and a complex love story. Cowney Sequoyah is a 19-year-old orphan who wants to break free from his tribal home in Cherokee and experience the greater world. Born with a malformed foot, he can’t join the Army, so he considers college. He takes a summer job at the Grove Park Inn to earn money and as a first step toward his escape.

Essie Stamper, another young Cherokee eager to try her wings, also takes a job, and the two become friends. Cowney, at least, hopes the friendship will blossom into something more.

The novel is also a mystery. The young daughter of one of the interned families goes missing, and Cowney is high on the suspect list. The white officers in charge of the investigation are only too willing to believe that this quiet, humble young Indian could be guilty of kidnapping and even murder.

There are troubling, unanswered questions, too, in Cowney’s family and life story, and as the novel progresses, he learns more about that — perhaps more than he really wants to know. A man who served with his late father and his uncle in the war emerges as an important character.

This is also a beautifully written novel about life in North Carolina’s Great Smoky Mountains around Cherokee, rich in nature as well as native myth, legend and culture. Bears and a free-spirited pet capuchin monkey are among both characters and symbols. Nature — streams, waterfalls, a cave, forests, fire, the earth and the bones buried in it, even the air we breathe — comes alive in this beautiful story.

Clapsaddle, a Cherokee who returned to the reservation area to teach and write after obtaining degrees from Yale and the College of William and Mary, obviously knows and loves the region and its history. Having researched the matter, she says she believes she is the first enrolled member of the Eastern Band of Cherokee to have a published novel.

The publisher is Fireside Industries Books, an imprint of the University Press of Kentucky, the scholarly publisher for the Commonwealth of Kentucky. Firesides Industries was established to promote the “Appalachian literary tradition by publishing new works and reissues of classics that greatly contribute to the region.” What a marvelous enterprise!

Linda Carter Brinson writes a blog about books, Briar Patch Books, at

Stay up-to-date on what's happening

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

  • Updated

Bookmarks NC will host virtual author talks on March 4 and March 9. At 7 p.m. March 4, Anne Lamott will discuss her newest book, "Dusk, Night Dawn: On Revival and Courage." In the book, Lamott uses her own recent marriage as a framework to explore how our lives can be enlarged through renewed commitment to ourselves and those around us. To register, order a copy of Lamott's book for $20 at The first 150 books will be signed. At 7 p.m. March 9, Leesa Cross-Smith and Naima Coster will discuss their newest books, "This Close to Okay" and "What's Mine and Yours," respectively. "This Close to Okay" is about a life-changing weekend between two strangers. "What's Mine and Yours" is a story about how race can affect even the closest of relationships. The event is pay what you can at Books are for sale at the event for $27 ("This Close to Okay") and $28 ("What's Mine and Yours"). Visit

Here are the bestsellers for the week that ended Saturday, Jan. 30, compiled from data from independent and chain bookstores, book wholesalers and independent distributors nationwide, powered by NPD BookScan © 2021 NPD Group. (Reprinted from Publishers Weekly, published by PWxyz LLC. © 2021, PWxyz LLC.) HARDCOVER FICTION 1. "The Russian" By James Patterson and James O. Born (Little, Brown) ...

On the afternoon of Jan. 24, two children's authors were lured to a Zoom meeting under false pretenses. David LaRochelle of White Bear Lake and Mike Wohnoutka of Minneapolis had been invited to take part in a panel discussion for the American Library Association. But when they clicked on the Zoom link, there was no panel — instead, they saw seven people beaming at them. "We have good news," ...

"Blood Grove" by Walter Mosley; Mulholland Books (320 pages, $27) ——— Walter Mosley’s books about Easy Rawlins are crime fiction, not history. But taken together, they’re a vivid picture of Black life in Los Angeles in the mid-20th century. Mosley writes in many genres, and he does it so well that the National Book Foundation gave him its 2020 Medal for Distinguished Contribution to American ...

CHICAGO – Debut author Nancy Johnson wanted to tell human interest stories when she was a broadcast news journalist years ago, but she recalls there were too few opportunities to do that. Now, the Chicago native has all the opportunity she can handle with her first book, “The Kindest Lie.” The novel tells the story of Ruth Tuttle, a Black engineer living in Bronzeville with her husband. The ...

Spring is coming ... soon? Here are six new paperbacks to help you get there — four fiction, two memoir, all recommended. "The Girl with the Louding Voice" by Abi Daré (Dutton, $14.99). This debut novel from Nigerian British author Daré was a New York Times bestseller, about a teenage girl in a Nigerian village who is determined to get an education but is pushed into a traditional early ...

“The Black Civil War Soldier: A Visual History of Conflict and Citizenship” by Deborah Willis; NYU Press (256 pages, $35) ——— It wasn’t just a war for freedom. It was a war for the future. Black soldiers during the Civil War weren’t just fighting for themselves. They were fighting for their children and all who came after. They were fighting for tomorrow. “The Black Civil War Soldier: A Visual ...

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alerts