What the 'spiritual but not religious' have in common with radical Protestants of 500 years ago

kAmu@C @G6C 2 564256[ @?6 @7 E96 3:886DE DE@C:6D :? p>6C:42? C6=:8:@? 92D 366? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A6H7@CF>]@C8^a_`h^`_^`f^:?\F\D\564=:?6\@7\49C:DE:2?:EJ\4@?E:?F6D\2E\C2A:5\A246^QmE96 C:D6 @7 E96 “}@?6D”k^2m[ 2 3C@25 E6C> 7@C A6@A=6 H9@ 5@ ?@E :56?E:7J H:E9 2 DA64:7:4 72:E9] %96 C6=:8:@FD=J F?277:=:2E65 ?@H >2<6 FA ;FDE @G6C @?6 BF2CE6C @7 E96 &]$] A@AF=2E:@?]k^Am

kAm(9:=6 E96 }@?6D :?4=F56 28?@DE:4D 2?5 2E96:DED[ >@DE A6@A=6 :? E9:D 42E68@CJ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A6H7@CF>]@C8^a_`g^_c^ad^H96?\2>6C:42?D\D2J\E96J\36=:6G6\:?\8@5\H92E\5@\E96J\>62?^QmC6E2:? 2 36=:67 :? v@5 @C D@>6 9:896C A@H6Ck^2m] |2?J 56D4C:36 E96>D6=G6D 2D “DA:C:EF2= 3FE ?@E C6=:8:@FD[” @C “$q}#[” 2D C6D62C496CD C676C E@ E96>]k^Am

kAmpD 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]D<D>]65F^A6@A=6^49C:DE@A96C\=\D496=:?^QmAC@76DD@C @7 E96@=@8Jk^2m 2E 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]FF2]@C8^Qm&?:E2C:2? &?:G6CD2=:DEk^2m 2?5 >F=E:C6=:8:@FD D6>:?2CJ[ x 6?4@F?E6C >2?J DEF56?ED H9@ 7:E H:E9:? E96 $q}# >@=5] %96J 2C6 DEF5J:?8 E@ 364@>6 492A=2:?D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^492A=2:?4J:?DE:EFE6]@C8^H9J\:?E6C72:E9^Qm:?E6C72:E9k^2m >:?:DE6CD 2?5 D@4:2= 24E:G:DED] qFE E96J >2J 36 DFCAC:D65 E@ <?@H 9@H >F49 E96J C6D6>3=6 46CE2:? !C@E6DE2?ED H9@ =:G65 7:G6 46?EFC:6D 28@ – D@>6 @7 E96 D@\42==65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]ADFAC6DD]@C8^3@@<D^E:E=6D^hfg\_\hc_cfc\`d\c]9E>=QmC25:42= C67@C>6CDk^2m H9@ DA=:E @77 7C@> k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^E96\=2DE:?8\:>A24E\@7\=FE96CD\C67@C>2E:@?\c\6DD6?E:2=\C625D\`_dhdbQm|2CE:? {FE96C’D #67@C>2E:@?k^2m]k^Am

k9am$A:C:EF2= 3FE ?@E C6=:8:@FDk^9am

kAm$49@=2CD 7C6E @G6C E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?444]86@C86E@H?]65F^3@5J\>:?5\DA:C:E^567:?:E:@?D\DA:C:EF2=:EJ\C6=:8:@?]A9AQmD=:AA6CJ 567:?:E:@?Dk^2m @7 “DA:C:EF2=” 2?5 “C6=:8:@FD]” (92E E96 2G6C286 A6CD@? E6?5D E@ >62? 3J “DA:C:EF2=” :D D66<:?8 @C 6IA6C:6?4:?8 2 4@??64E:@? H:E9 2 8C62E6C C62=:EJ[ 9@H6G6C E96J F?56CDE2?5 :E] |62?H9:=6[ “C6=:8:@FD” @7E6? >62?D 36=@?8:?8 E@ 2 8C@FA H:E9 DA64:7:4 5@4EC:?6D 2?5 C:EF2=D]k^Am

kAm%96 DA:C:EF2= 3FE ?@E C6=:8:@FD 2C6 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_hb^24AC@7i@D@^hfg_`hhbc`aa`]__`]___`Qm:?56A6?56?E D66<6CDk^2m[ >2?J @7 H9@> AC2J[ >65:E2E6[ 5@ J@82 2?5 @E96C DA:C:EF2= AC24E:46D @FED:56 E96 4@?7:?6D @7 2 A2CE:4F=2C EC25:E:@?]k^Am

kAm%96 E96@=@8:2? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D49@=2C]8@@8=6]4@>^4:E2E:@?DnFD6Cl4qJ:B:|ppppyU2>Aj9=l6?Qm{:?52 |6C4252?E6k^2m DA6?E D6G6C2= J62CD :?E6CG:6H:?8 $q}#D] x? 96C 3@@< “k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^5@:]@C8^`_]`_hb^24AC@7i@D@^hfg_`hhhb`__a]__`]___`Qmq6=:67 H:E9@FE q@C56CDk^2m”[ D96 :56?E:7:6D D@>6 4@>>@? G2=F6D] $q}#D E6?5 E@ 36 :?5:G:5F2=:DE:4[ ECFDE:?8 E96:C @H? 6IA6C:6?46 2?5 :?EF:E:@? 2D 2 8F:56] %96J C6;64E 4=2:>D E92E 2?J @?6 C6=:8:@? 4@?E2:?D E96 F=E:>2E6[ 6I4=FD:G6 ECFE9[ 3FE E96J 2=D@ 36=:6G6 C6=:8:@?D A@DD6DD H:D5@> 2?5 @776C “k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]H@C=5H:D5@>]4@>^AF3=:4^G:6HA57^5672F=E]2DAIn2CE:4=6\E:E=6l!2E9D0%92E0{6250E@0E960$2>60$F>>:E03J0p?2?520r@@>2C2DH2>J]A57Qm>2?J A2E9Dk^2m E@ E96 D2>6 DF>>:E]”k^Am

kAm#6AF5:2E:?8 “@C82?:K65 C6=:8:@?” 2D 2 32DE:@? @7 5@8>2E:D> 2?5 >@C2= 9JA@4C:DJ :D 4@>>@? 2>@?8 $q}#D] %96J @7E6? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^4@==686G:==6:?DE:EFE6]@C8^362C:?8D^=:DE6?:?8\DA:C:EF2=\C6=:8:@FD^Qm6IA=:4:E=J C6;64Ek^2m H92E E96J F?56CDE2?5 E@ 36 46?EC2= r9C:DE:2? 36=:67D] %96J 5@?’E H6=4@>6 2 >6DD286 E92E v@5 =@G6D E96> 3FE H:== D6?5 E96> E@ 96== 7@C ?@E 2446AE:?8 y6DFD] qFE >2?J 4@?E:?F6 E@ 6IA6C:>6?E H:E9 C:EF2=D 2?5 AC2J6CD E92E 5C2H @? 6DE23=:D965 C6=:8:@?D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^C6=:8:@??6HD]4@>^a_`h^_c^`e^7@C\>:==6??:2=D\>JDE:4:D>\D9@HD\2\A2E9\E@\E96:C\9@>6\72:E9D^Qm:?4=F5:?8 r9C:DE:2?:EJk^2m]k^Am

k9amp $A:C:EF2= #67@C>2E:@?k^9am

kAmx? `dag[ {FE96C2? A2DE@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C:E2??:42]4@>^3:@8C2A9J^$632DE:2?\uC2?4<Qm$632DE:2? uC2?4<k^2m 564:565 96’5 925 6?@F89 @7 @C82?:K65 C6=:8:@?] s66A=J 5:DEFC365 3J E96 >@C2= 72:=FC6D @7 AC@76DD:?8 r9C:DE:2?D[ 96 C6D:8?65 9:D AF=A:E]k^Am

kAm%96 !C@E6DE2?E #67@C>2E:@? 925 C646?E=J DA=:E E96 r9C:DE:2?D @7 (6DE6C? tFC@A6 :?E@ G2C:@FD 724E:@?D[ A:EE:?8 #@>2? r2E9@=:4D 282:?DE {FE96C2?D[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]49C:DE:2?:EJE@52J]4@>^9:DE@CJ^A6@A=6^>@G6CD2?5D92<6CD^F=C:49\KH:?8=:]9E>=Qm+H:?8=:2?Dk^2m – H9@D6 :?7=F6?46 =:G6D @? :? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?6H]4C4?2]@C8^H6=4@>6^36=:67D^C67@C>65\2446?E^H92E\C67@C>65Qm#67@C>65 49FC496Dk^2m E@52J – 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C:E2??:42]4@>^E@A:4^p?232AE:DEDQmp?232AE:DEDk^2m[ H9@ AC24E:465 25F=E 32AE:D>] %96J 4@F=5?’E 2== 36 C:89E[ D@ uC2?4< 4@?4=F565 E96J >FDE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^3@@<D]8@@8=6]4@>^3@@<Dn:5l3}`!FsD!c@4rU2>AjAC:?ED64l7C@?E4@G6CRGl@?6A286U2>AjBl2Ta_=6EE6CTa_E@Ta_;@9?Ta_42>A2?FDU2>Aj7l72=D6Qm2== 36 HC@?8k^2m]k^Am

kAmk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^7:=6D^cahc_b^@C:8:?2=^7:=6\a_a``_ah\`b\`Cd8cEJ];A8n:I=:3lC3\`]`]_U2>AjBlcdU2>Aj2FE@l7@C>2EU2>Aj2=ElQ H:5E9lQ`__TQ ^m k6>m|2CE:? {FE96C[ 5C2H? 96C6 3FC?:?8 E96 A@A6’D E9C62E E@ 6I4@>>F?:42E6 9:>[ :D E96 >@DE 72>@FD #67@C>2E:@?\6C2 C67@C>6C[ 3FE E96C6 H6C6 >2?J >@C6] !9@E@ 3J p?? #@?2? !:4EFC6D^!C:?E r@==64E@C G:2 v6EEJ x>286Dk^6>mk^Am

kAmuC2?4< 564=2C65 E92E E96 ECF6 49FC49 H2D E96 :?G:D:3=6 76==@HD9:A @7 A6@A=6 H9@ H6C6 :?DECF4E65[ ?@E 3J E96 A@A6 @C E96 q:3=6[ 3FE 3J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^3C:==]4@>^G:6H^3@@<^654@==^hfgh__cbhb`gh^q!_____f]I>=QmE96 5:G:?6 DA2C<k^2m H:E9:?] w6 3642>6 2 =625:?8 7:8FC6 :? 2 7@C> @7 C25:42= !C@E6DE2?E:D> E92E D49@=2CD H@F=5 =2E6C 42== E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^2C49:G6]@C8^DEC62>^#6?2:DD2?46p?5#67@C>2E:@?(:==:2>v:=36CE`hhf^#6?2:DD2?46Ta_2?5Ta_#67@C>2E:@?TarTa_(:==:2>Ta_v:=36CETa_Tag`hhfTah05;GF]EIEQm“$A:C:EF2=:DED”k^2m @C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]8FE6?36C8]@C8^63@@<D^achbcQm“DA:C:EF2= C67@C>6CD”k^2m] %9:D 5:G6CD6 42DE @7 492C24E6CD 5@H?A=2J65 @C C6;64E65 E96 @FEH2C5 EC2AA:?8D @7 C6=:8:@?[ DF49 2D C:EF2=D 2?5 D24C2>6?ED] (92E C62==J >2EE6C65 H2D 6249 :?5:G:5F2=’D 5:C64E 6?4@F?E6C H:E9 v@5]k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C:E2??:42]4@>^3:@8C2A9J^w2?D\s6?4<Qmw2?D s6?4<k^2m[ H9@ :D D@>6E:>6D 4C65:E65 2D E96 7:CDE k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^3C:==]4@>^G:6H^3@@<^654@==^hfgh_cfc``_cg^q6;]hfgh__c`dc_ad]:\dfc0__g]I>=Qm$A:C:EF2=:DEk^2m[ 56D4C:365 E9:D 6IA6C:6?46 2D E96 “:??6C (@C5” DA62<:?8 7C@> H:E9:? 2 A6CD@?’D D@F=] “%96 (@C5 @7 v@5 :D 2=C625J H:E9 J@F 367@C6 J@F D66< :E[” k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^3@@<D]8@@8=6]4@>^3@@<Dn:5lF>Ar"$">D7|rU2>AjA8l!p`_fU2>Aj=A8l!p`_fU2>Aj5Bl56?4<ZTaa%96Z(@C5Z@7Zv@5Z:DZ2=C625JZH:E9ZJ@FZ367@C6ZJ@FZD66<Z:ETaaU2>AjD@FC46l3=U2>Aj@EDlC"*Ig{=z2}U2>AjD:8lpr7&b&aG+4<!h;Fx\9?)x4:5'J~=08|fC"U2>Aj9=l6?U2>AjD2l)U2>AjG65la29&ztH:)_!6|0\bKp9)q?6pzw&"gr}|"epueqp8rtp|RGlD?:AA6EU2>AjBlE96Ta_H@C5Ta_@7Ta_8@5Ta_:DTa_2=C625JTa_H:E9Ta_J@FU2>Aj7l72=D6Qm96 HC@E6k^2m] &?=:<6 EJA:42= !C@E6DE2?ED[ s6?4< 2?5 E96 @E96C $A:C:EF2=:DED D2H E96 q:3=6 2D C65F?52?E] xED AFCA@D6 H2D E@ 4@?7:C> H92E E96 36=:6G6C 2=C625J <?6H 7C@> E96 962CE]k^Am

kAmq642FD6 E96 :??6C (@C5 C6D:565 H:E9:? 2== 9F>2? 36:?8D[ 46CE2:? $A:C:EF2=:DED 96=5 E92E D2=G2E:@? H2D ?@E =:>:E65 E@ r9C:DE:2?D]k^Am

kAm“r@?D:56C 2D E9J 3C@E96CD[” k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^3@@<D]8@@8=6]4@>^3@@<Dn:5lF>Ar"$">D7|rU2>AjA8l!p`_fU2>Aj=A8l!p`_fU2>Aj5Bl56?4<ZTaa%96Z(@C5Z@7Zv@5Z:DZ2=C625JZH:E9ZJ@FZ367@C6ZJ@FZD66<Z:ETaaU2>AjD@FC46l3=U2>Aj@EDlC"*Ig{=z2}U2>AjD:8lpr7&b&aG+4<!h;Fx\9?)x4:5'J~=08|fC"U2>Aj9=l6?U2>AjD2l)U2>AjG65la29&ztH:)_!6|0\bKp9)q?6pzw&"gr}|"epueqp8rtp|RGlD?:AA6EU2>AjBlTaa4@?D:56CTa_2DTa_E9JTa_3C@E96CDTaaU2>Aj7l72=D6QmHC@E6 uC2?4<k^2m[ “2== … H9@ 762C v@5 2?5 H@C< C:89E6@FD?6DD[” 6G6? E9@D6 H9@ ?6G6C 962C5 @7 r9C:DE] %96C6 H2D ?@ ?665 E@ D6?5 >:DD:@?2C:6D E@ @E96C ?2E:@?D] %96J 2=C625J 925 E96 w@=J $A:C:E E@ E6249 2?5 DA:C:EF2==J “32AE:K6” E96>]k^Am

kAm!2CE=J 3642FD6 @7 A6CD64FE:@? 2?5 A2CE=J 3642FD6 @7 E96:C 6>A92D:D @? E96 :?5:G:5F2=[ E96 $A:C:EF2=:DED C2C6=J 7@C>65 DECF4EFC65 4@>>F?:E:6D] %@52J[ E96J 2C6 >@DE=J 7@C8@EE6? @FED:56 @7 49FC49 9:DE@CJ 4@FCD6D] qFE E96:C :?7=F6?46 D92A65 E96 7@F?5:?8 @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^BF2<6C:?7@]@C8^:?56IQm"F2<6C:D>k^2m[ 2 3C2?49 @7 r9C:DE:2?:EJ E92E[ E@ E9:D G6CJ 52J[ D66<D E96 8F:52?46 @7 E96 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]AJ>]@C8^72:E9\2?5\AC24E:46^6IA6C:6?46\2?5\72:E9^E96\=:89E\H:E9:?^Qm:??6C =:89Ek^2m]k^Am

kAm,k6>mtIA=@C6 E96 :?E6CD64E:@? @7 72:E9[ A@=:E:4D[ 2CED 2?5 4F=EFC6 :? 2? 6>2:= ?6HD=6EE6C]k^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^FD^?6HD=6EE6CD^E9:D\H66<\:?\C6=:8:@?\fe^nFE>0D@FC46l%r&$U2>AjFE>0>65:F>l:?=:?6\=:?<U2>AjFE>042>A2:8?l?6HD=6EE6C\E6IEU2>AjFE>04@?E6?ElC6=:8:@?\6IA=@C6Qm$:8? FA 7@C %9:D (66< :? #6=:8:@?]k^2m.k^Am

k9am(92E’D @=5 :D ?6H 282:?k^9am

kAm%96 A2C2==6=D 36EH66? E96 !C@E6DE2?E $A:C:EF2=:DED 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]A6HC6D62C49]@C8^724E\E2?<^a_`e^_g^ac^H9J\2>6C:42D\?@?6D\=67E\C6=:8:@?\369:?5^Qm>2?J 4@?E6>A@C2CJ $q}#Dk^2m 42? 36 DEC:<:?8] q@E9 2C6 C6AF=D65 3J E96 6E9:42= 72:=:?8D 2?5 6I4=FD:G:D> @7 C6=:8:@FD 4@>>F?:E:6D] q@E9 6>A92D:K6 E96 C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ @7 E96 :?5:G:5F2= E@ 7@==@H E96:C @H? DA:C:EF2= BF6DE] q@E9 36=:6G6 E92E 2FE96?E:4 6IA6C:6?46 @7 v@5 @C F=E:>2E6 C62=:EJ :D 2G2:=23=6 E@ 2== A6@A=6[ C682C5=6DD @7 E96:C DA64:7:4 36=:67D] (96C62D uC2?4< 2?5 s6?4< FD65 E96 62C=J AC:?E:?8 AC6DD E@ DAC625 E96:C >6DD286[ E@52J 2 DA:C:EF2= E62496C >:89E C64@C5 2 A@542DE @C *@F%F36 G:56@]k^Am

kAmqFE :E :D :>A@CE2?E E@ 6>A92D:K6 E92E E96 $A:C:EF2=:DED H6C6 DE:== 564:565=J r9C:DE:2?] r@?EC2CJ E@ >@DE $q}#D[ E96J 4@?D:56C65 y6DFD r9C:DE E96 2FE9@C:E2E:G6 C6G62=6C @7 ECFE9] $@>6 36=:6G65 96 H@F=5 D@@? C6EFC? E@ t2CE9 7@C k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C:E2??:42]4@>^E@A:4^>:==6??:2=:D>^|:==6??:2=:D>\7C@>\E96\#6?2:DD2?46\E@\E96\>@56C?\H@C=5Qm9:D $64@?5 r@>:?8k^2m 2?5 H2:E65 2D 6IA64E2?E=J 2D 2?J 6?5 E:>6D\7@4FD65 7F?52>6?E2=:DE 5@6D E@52J] %96J >2J 92G6 D66? @E96C C6=:8:@?D 2D G2=:5 A2E9D[ 3FE E96J 5:5?’E EFC? E@ E96> 2D C6D@FC46D 7@C DA:C:EF2= AC24E:46]k^Am

kAmtG6? D@[ E96 $A:C:EF2=:DED 56>@?DEC2E6 E92E E96 G2=F6D 2?5 2EE:EF56D @7 $q}#D 2C6 72C 7C@> 2 ?6H 56G6=@A>6?E] %96J HC6DE=65 H:E9 D:>:=2C 5:77:4F=E:6D :? C6=:8:@? 2?5 42>6 FA H:E9 D:>:=2C 2?DH6CD] pD k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]D<J=:89EA2E9D]4@>^A286^AC@5F4E^hfg\`\dhcfb\d`d\gQmE96 DA:C:EF2==J :?56A6?56?E 4@?E:?F6 E@ D66< H:D5@>k^2m 2?5 >62?:?8[ E96J 42? 7:?5 8@@5 4@>A2?J :? E96 C25:42= C67@C>6CD @7 2 3J8@?6 286]k^Am

kAm000k^Am

kAmk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]E964@?G6CD2E:@?]4@>^7:=6D^bbgdhg^@C:8:?2=^7:=6\a_a__dah\fggf`\`8d8D6d];A8nHl`agU2>Aj9l`agQ ^mk^Am

k5:GmkAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]2ED]65F^Qm$E2CC z:?8 $49@@= 7@C E96 |:?:DECJ :D 2 >6>36C @7 E96 pDD@4:2E:@? @7 %96@=@8:42= $49@@=Dk^2mk^Am%96 p%$ :D 2 7F?5:?8 A2CE?6C @7 %96 r@?G6CD2E:@? &]$]k^5:Gm

kAmr9C:DE@A96C $496=:? 5@6D ?@E H@C< 7@C[ 4@?DF=E[ @H? D92C6D :? @C C646:G6 7F?5:?8 7C@> 2?J 4@>A2?J @C @C82?:K2E:@? E92E H@F=5 36?67:E 7C@> E9:D 2CE:4=6[ 2?5 92D 5:D4=@D65 ?@ C6=6G2?E 277:=:2E:@?D 36J@?5 E96:C 24256>:4 2AA@:?E>6?E]k^Am

kAmYYYk^Am