Remember JG Black: The final battle and an unanswered question

kAm%9:D :D E96 7:?2= A2CE @7 2 D6C:6D @7 DE@C:6D 23@FE 9:>]k^Am

k9bm%96 u:?2= q2EE=6 – $F?52 $EC2:Ek^9bm

kAm&$$ w@FDE@? 2?5 w|p$ !6CE9 =67E E96 32EE=6 D46?6 E92E ?:89E 2E 9:89 DA665[ 492CE:?8 2 b__\>:=6 H6DEH2C5 4@FCD6 E@ q2E2G:2[ D66<:?8 C67F86 2?5 7F6=] kDEC@?8mpFE9@C y2>6D s] w@C?7:D496Ck^DEC@?8mi “%96 E6CC@C E96J 925 6IA6C:6?465 H2D 2 7C:89E6?:?8 AC6G:6H @7 E96 EC:2=D E96 &]$] }2GJ H@F=5 7246 27E6C 52C< 282:?DE E96:C H6==\AC24E:465 6?6>J] q67@C6 E96 H2C[ A=6?EJ @7 C62D@?D H6C6 7@F?5 — 4@>A6==:?8 6?@F89 :? A6246E:>6 — E@ ?68=64E 5:77:4F=E 2?5 52?86C@FD ?:89E 6I6C4:D6D] p5>:C2= y2>6D ~] #:492C5D@?[ 4@>>2?56C :? 49:67 @7 E96 &?:E65 $E2E6D 7=66E[ HC@E6[ :? E96 6C2 367@C6 C252C[ 4=@D6\:? ?:89E 6I6C4:D6D 3C@F89E 2 8C62E C:D< @7 4@==:D:@?[ =@DD @7 =:76[ 2?5 6IA6?D:G6 D9:A C6A2:CD] pD 2 C6DF=E @7 9:D 96D:E2?4J[ }2GJ 4@>>2?56CD H@F=5 ?@E D66 24EF2= ?:89EE:>6 E@CA65@ 2EE24<D =2F?4965 3J 92C5\492C8:?8 4CF:D6C 2?5 56DEC@J6C 42AE2:?D F?E:= E96J 4@?7C@?E65 E96 C62= E9:?8 F?56C E96 =62DE 7@C8:G:?8 @7 4:C4F>DE2?46D] p?5 7@C 2== E96:C D24C:7:46D[ E96 52?86C E@ E96 sFE49 t2DE x?5:6D =@@>65 2D 8C62E 2D 6G6C]”k^Am

kAmpE 52H?[ =@@<@FED D62C4965 E96 9@C:K@?[ C6G62=:?8 ?@ 6?6>J D9:AD ?62C3J 2?5 :E D66>65 C62D@?23=6 7@C E96 7:CDE E:>6 E@ 9@A6 E92E E96J >:89E 6D42A6 7FCE96C 4@>32E]k^Am

kAm%96 y2A2?6D6 925 D:?8=65 @FE q2E2G:2’D q2?E6? q2J[ H96C6 E96:C EC2?DA@CED H@F=5 56=:G6C x>A6C:2= y2A2?6D6 `eE9 pC>J EC@@AD 2?5 >2E6C:2=D] %96 y2A2?6D6 AFE 6?@F89 A=2??:?8[ D9:AD[ A=2?6D[ 2?5 >6? :?E@ E96 :?G2D:@? 7=66E E@ 4@?5F4E 2 DH66A @7 E96 ?@CE9 2?5 D@FE9 4@2DE @7 y2G2 :? 2 A:?496C >@G6>6?E E@ 4=62C E96 D62 @7 p==:65 H2CD9:AD] %96 p==:6D H6C6 42F89E F?2H2C6 @7 ;FDE 9@H BF:4<=J E96 C6=6?E=6DD 6?6>J H2D E@ =2?5:?8 2D9@C6 2E 3@E9 6?5D @7 E96 :D=2?5]k^Am

kAmp==:65 DFCG6:==2?46 C6BF:C65 2:C4C27E 2?5 2:C4C6HD :? DF77:4:6?E ?F>36CD E@ 42?G2D E96 D62 =2?6D =625:?8 E@ 2?5 7C@> $F?52 $EC2:E] $F?52 H2D E96 82E6H2J D@FE9 E@ E96 C6=2E:G6 D276EJ @7 pFDEC2=:2] {24<:?8 4C:E:42= C6D@FC46D[ E96 p==:6D 925 ?@ C6=:23=6 :?7@C>2E:@? E@ D92C6 H:E9 D9:AD 2E D62] pD :E EFC?65 @FE[ E96 :?7@C>2E:@? E92E H2D 2G2:=23=6 2CC:G65 E@@ =2E6 E@ AC6G6?E E96 4CF6= 2?5 6IA=@D:G6 4=:>2I]k^Am

kAmpE 23@FE `bb_ @? E96 27E6C?@@? @7 $2EFC52J[ u63] ag[ `hca[ 3@E9 D9:AD 2CC:G65 D276=J 2E E96 42A:E2=[ q2E2G:2] %96 D:89E 8C66E:?8 E96:C 6J6D H2D 56AC6DD:?8 E@ =@@< FA@?] %96 56DECF4E:@? H2D D9C@F565 3J 4=@F5D @7 3=24< D>@<6] %96 D>@<6 5C:7E65 @G6C @:=J H2E6C H9:49 H2D =:EE6C65 H:E9 563C:D] %96 C2?4:5 D>6== @7 3FC?:?8 @:=[ 3F:=5:?8D 2?5 3FC?E G686E2E:@? A6C>62E65 E96 @?46\3FDE=:?8 A@CE @7 %2?5;@?8 !C:@<] $6G6C2= >6C492?E D9:AD 4@F=5 36 D66? C6DE:?8 2E @55 2?8=6D @? E96 92C3@C 7=@@C] (92E E96 y2A2?6D6 925 D>2D965 E9C66 52JD AC:@C H:E9 3@>3D =2J 232?5@?65 :? A=246] %96 y2G2?6D6 925 232?5@?65 E96:C 42A:E2= 29625 @7 E96 25G2?4:?8 :?G2D:@? EC@@AD]k^Am

kAm%92E 27E6C?@@? E96 4C6H E@@< @? H92E 7F6= E96 sFE49 H@F=5 2==@H H9:=6 E96 4C6H =23@C65 E@ EC2?D76C 23@FE b__ g\:?49 AC@;64E:=6D 2?5 FAH2C5 @7 g__ D6CG:46 492C86D 3J 92?5 7C@> 96C 27E >282K:?6D E@ E96 7@CH2C5 >282K:?6D] %9:D H2D 2? “2== 92?5D” 6G@=FE:@? @? H9:49 E96 D9:A’D G6CJ 6I:DE6?46 >:89E 56A6?5[ 2?5 6G6CJ D2:=@C <?6H :E] %96 962GJ Wae_\A@F?5X AC@;64E:=6D H6C6 AFE :?E@ ;6CCJ\C:8865 D=:?8D >256 @7 42?G2D 2?5 H@@5[ 42CC:65 3J A2CE:6D @7 7@FC >6? 6249[ E96? 2EE24965 E@ 5@==:6D 2?5 >2?92?5=65 H:E9 8C62E A9JD:42= 677@CE ?62C=J E96 7F== =6?8E9 @7 E96 D9:A] %96 >6? ?68@E:2E65 A2DD286H2JD 2?5 =2556CD H9:=6 >2<:?8 EFC?D 2C@F?5 E:89E 4@C?6CD H9:49 >256 E96 E2D< 6I46AE:@?2==J 5:77:4F=E]k^Am

kAm{2E6C E92E 27E6C?@@?[ @C56CD 42>6 E9C@F89 E@ w|p$ !6CE9 2?5 &$$ w@FDE@? 2?5 w}{|$ tG6CED6?[ 2 sFE49 56DEC@J6C 2=D@ :? q2E2G:2 2E E96 E:>6 — “%pzt w~&$%~} p}s t't#%$t} &}st# *~&# ~#st#$ p}s !#~rtts x} r~|!p}* %~ %yx{p%yp! {tp'x}v !#x~z p$ $~~} p$ r~}'t}xt}% pu%t# sp#z]” %96 A=2? H2D E@ >2<6 7@C %;:=2E;2A 2?5 @?46 E96C6[ A:4< FA DEC2?565 A6CD@??6= E96? AC@4665 E@ pFDEC2=:2]k^Am

kAm!6CE9 2?5 w@FDE@? =67E A@CE 2E `eca 9@FCD Wcica A]>]X[ @?=J 92=7 C67F6=65[ D9@CE @7 2>>F?:E:@? 2?5 F?6D4@CE65] s:DC682C5:?8 E96 H2C?:?8 23@FE 2 y2A2?6D6 7=66E 2AAC@249:?8 (6DE\y2G2[ r2AE2:? (2==6C W$~!pX :? w|p$ !6CE9 :>>65:2E6=J D6E 4@FCD6 7@C $F?52 $EC2:E :? 2? 677@CE E@ >2<6 2 9:89\DA665 K:8K28 CF? E9C@F89 $F?52 $EC2:E 7@C E96 D@FE96C=J A@CE @7 %;:=2E;2A]k^Am

kAmr2AE] (2==6C D6?E 2 =2DE >6DD286 :? 6I2DA6C2E:@? E@ 9:D DFA6C:@CDi “x rp}}~% !t#$&pst t't#%$t} %~ r~|t (x%w |t p| !#~rttsx}v]”k^Am

kAmtG6CED6? DEF33@C?=J C6>2:?65 :? A@CE 5F6 E@ 2 “>6492?:42=” :DDF6 H:E9 ?@ DE62> FA E@ 7:C6 96C 3@:=6CD 3FE H@F=5 86E F?56CH2J D6G6C2= 9@FCD =2E6C 2E 23@FE h A]>] Wa`__X] ~?46 2E D62[ D96 D6?E E9:D >6DD286i “$tp qp%%{t x} !#~v#t$$ ~uu $%] }xrw~{p$ !~x}%]” {2E6C E92E ?:89E[ w}|{$ tG6CED6? 76== G:4E:> E@ EH@ y2A2?6D6 56DEC@J6CD Wxy} $9:C2<F>@ 2?5 xy} |FC2<F>@X[ H9:49 :?7=:4E65 244FC2E6 8F?7:C6[ 42FD:?8 =@DD @7 96C 7:C6 4@?EC@= 6BF:A>6?E 2?5 AFEE:?8 96C 27E c]f\:?49 8F? @FE @7 24E:@?] tG6CED6? >256 2 56DA6C2E6 2EE6>AE E@ 86E 2H2J[ 3FE E96 =2C86C 2?5 72DE6C y2A2?6D6 D9:AD AFCDF65 E96 3FC?:?8 sFE49 56DEC@J6C[ 244FC2E6=J 7:C:?8 2D E96J 5:5 D@] %96 4@>>2?5:?8 @77:46C D@F89E E@ 5C:G6 9:D D9:A 28C@F?5 @? 4@C2= C667D ?62C $63@6<@6 xD=2?5 C2E96C E92? D:?< :? 566A H2E6C] %96 8C@F?565 D9:A H2D 232?5@?65 2E _b__ H:E9 F?4@?EC@==65 7:C6D 2?5 >F49 =@DD @7 =:76]k^Am

kAm!@DE\H2C y2A2?6D6 C64@C5D :?5:42E6 E92E E96 F?4964<65 7:C6D C624965 96C 27E6C >282K:?6 2?5 D96 G:@=6?E=J 3=6H FA @? E96 27E6C?@@? @7 |2C49 `]k^Am

kAmp7E6C (@C=5 (2C xx[ 7C@> 2 5@4F>6?E HC:EE6? 3J tG6CED6?’D 4@>>2?5:?8 @77:46C W:? 2? 2EE6>AE E@ ;FDE:7J 9:D 24E:@?DX[ E96 sFE49 56DEC@J6C 925 56=:36C2E6=J D@F89E E@ 2G@:5 4@?E24E H:E9 E96 6?6>J E92E ?:89E]k^Am

kAmkDEC@?8mpFE9@C s@?2=5 |] z69? yC]k^DEC@?8mi $9:A’D 4@>A2?J ?@E @? 5FEJ 3682? E@ =F8 4@ED[ >2EEC6DD6D @C 3=2?<6ED E@AD:56 :? 2 7@8 @7 6I92FDE:@? 2?5 AC@>AE=J 76== :?E@ F?4@?D4:@FD?6DD] %96 H@CDE D66>65 E@ 36 @G6C[ 2?5 E96 J@F?8 @C >@C6 ?2ïG6 >6? 76=E E96J H@F=5 >2<6 :E @FE @7 E96 42>A2:8? D276=J] p== 2=@?8 E96 =6?8E9 @7 E96 8C62E D9:A’D FAA6C 564<[ w@FDE@?’D D=66A\56AC:G65 2?5 5C2:?65 >6? H6C6 42E49:?8 H92E C6DE E96J 4@F=5] ~G6C9625 E9C@F89 2 76H 4=@F5D 4@F=5 36 D66? 2 3C:==:2?E >@@?[ 2=>@DE 7F==j G:D:3:=:EJ H2D 8@@5[ 2?5 E96 E6>A6C2EFC6 >:=5]k^Am

kAm!6CE9 2?5 w@FDE@?[ :? 4@=F>?[ K:8\K28865 ?@CE962DE @7 !2?5;2?8 xD=2?5 H9:=6 >2<:?8 :? 6I46DD @7 a_ <?@ED] %96 D9:AD E96? 7@==@H65 2 72>:=:2C D9:AA:?8 =2?6 A2C2==6= E@ E96 4@2DE] $@@? E96J H6C6 H:E9:? b_ >:?FE6D @7 E96 6?EC2?46 E@ $F?52 $EC2:E] p =@?6 y2A2?6D6 56DEC@J6C H2D @? A2EC@= E@ E96:C D@FE9H6DE] xy} w2CF<2K6 DE2CE=65 E96 DE2E:@?2CJ e__ E@? sFE49 A2EC@= 3@2E[ #6:86C[ H:E9 96C D62C49=:89E 2D E96 4C6H 9FCC:65=J AF==65 FA E96:C 2?49@C] %96 y2A2?6D6 56DEC@J6C D@@? @G6CA@H6C65 2?5 D2?< E96 A2EC@= 3@2E H:E9 8F?7:C6] w2CF<2K6 C6EFC?65 E@ 96C A2EC@=]k^Am

kAm}@E =@?8 E96C627E6C[ =@@<@FED 23@2C5 w|p$ !6CE9[ H9:49 H2D :? E96 =625[ ?@E:465 2 5:> D:=9@F6EE6 =@H 2?5 52C< @? E96 H2E6C D@>6 5:DE2?46 29625]k^Am

kAmkDEC@?8mpFE9@C y2>6D s] w@C?7:D496Ck^DEC@?8mi “r2AE] (2==6C @C56C65 9:D D:8?2=>2? E@ 492==6?86 FD:?8 E96 p=5:D D:8?2= =2>A] %96 D:8?2= H2D C6A62E65[ 7@==@H65 D64@?5D =2E6C 3J 2 DEC62> @7 ?@?D6?D6 :? 2 8C66?:D9 =:89E 7C@> E96 F?:56?E:7:65 D:=9@F6EE6] %92E :D H96? E96 F?:56?E:7:65 G6DD6= EFC?65[ C6G62=:?8 E96 E6==E2=6 D:=9@F6EE6 @7 2 y2A2?6D6 56DEC@J6C H9:49 3682? >2<:?8 D>@<6] p3@2C5 w@FDE@?[ E96 7:CDE 9:?E E@ 2?J@?6 E92E 2?JE9:?8 H2D 2>:DD H2D E96 DF556?[ DE2CE=:?8 7=2D9 2?5 D9@4< @7 E96 !6CE9’D >2:? 32EE6CJ 8F?D C:AA:?8 :?E@ E96 ?:89E FA 29625]” pE @?46[ 2 C65 '6CJ 7=2C6 H2D D66? 2C49:?8 D<JH2C5 7C@> E96 G:4:?:EJ @7 E96 F?:56?E:7:65 D9:AD] pE E92E >@>6?E 6I24E=J 9@H >2?J D9:AD E96J 72465[ 2?5 @7 H92E EJA6[ H2D F?<?@H?]k^Am

kAmpE 2AAC@I:>2E6=J ``b_ 9@FCD[ w@FDE@? EC2?D>:EE65 H92E H@F=5 36 E96 =2DE 4=F6 E@ 96C 72E6] %96 y2A2?6D6 AC@A282?5:DED 925 2=C625J 8=667F==J 2?5 C6A62E65=J 2??@F?465 E96:C D:?<:?8 @7 “%96 v2==@A:?8 v9@DE @7 E96 y2G2 r@2DE]” %9:D ?:89E[ E96:C E:>6 925 4@>6] r2AE] #@@<D :?7@C>65 #62C p5>:C2= v=2DD7@C5[ 9:D :>>65:2E6 DFA6C:@C[ 2=D@ r@>>2?56C @7 E96 $:IE66?E9 }2G2= s:DEC:4E[ #25:@ r@CC68:5@C[ 2?5 E@ E96 r9:67 @7 }2G2= ~A6C2E:@?Dik^Am

kAm“t}t|* u~#rt$ t}vpvts]”k^Am

kAm~FE @7 2 4C6H @7 `[_ec[ &$$ w@FDE@? =@DE eba @77:46CD 2?5 >6?]k^Am

kAmsFC:?8 E96 32EE=6[ w@FDE@? H2D DF?< 3J 2D >2?J 2D 7@FC E@CA65@ 9:ED 2D H6== 2D ?F>6C@FD AC@;64E:=6 DEC:<6D @7 G2C:@FD 42=:36CD] %96 4@>>2?5:?8 @77:46C :? w@FDE@?[ r2AE] p=36CE w2C@=5 #@@<D[ &$}p `h`c[ H2D <:==65 3J D9C2A?6= 2D 9:D D9:A 42>6 E@ 2 DE@A] y2A2?6D6 56DEC@J6CD DH2C>65 @G6C 96C[ >249:?6\8F??:?8 E96 564<D 2D H6== 2D D2:=@CD :? E96 H2E6C 2?5 AF>A:?8 D96==D :?E@ E96 5:D23=65 D9:A] p 76H >:?FE6D =2E6C[ E96 82==2?E w@FDE@?[ 96C ?2>6 HC:EE6? :>A6C:D923=J :? E96 C64@C5D @7 96C@:D>[ C@==65 @G6C 2?5 D2?<[ 96C 6?D:8? DE:== 7=J:?8] w@FDE@? DF44F>365 E@ @G6CH96=>:?8 y2A2?6D6 7@C46D[ 3FE ?@E 367@C6 9:EE:?8 E9C66 6?6>J 56DEC@J6CD 2?5 D:?<:?8 @?6 >:?6DH66A6C H9:=6 7:89E:?8 2=@?6 W!6CE9 92G:?8 2=C625J 366? DF?<]X] w6C DFCG:G@CD H6C6 A:4<65 FA 3J y2A2?6D6 D9:AD 2?5 D6?E E@ AC:D@? 42>AD :? $@FE962DE pD:2] w@FDE@? DFCG:G@CD 96=A65 3F:=5 2 ?2CC@H 82F86 C2:=H2J H:E9 A:4<D 2?5 D9@G6=D]k^Am

kAmkDEC@?8m%96 BF6DE:@? C6>2:?D F?2?DH6C65j H92E 92AA6?65 E@ ‘yv’ q=24<nk^DEC@?8mk^Am

kAm(6 H:== ?6G6C <?@H H92E E@@< 9:D =:76 E92E ?:89E] (6 5@ <?@H E96 @?D=2F89E @7 A@:?E\3=2?< 3FCDE:?8 D96==D[ D9C2A?6=[ A=FD E96 FD6 @7 >249:?6 8F?D 2:>65 2E E96 D9:A 2?5 E9@D6 :? E96 H2E6C[ H2D 56G2DE2E:?8] pD 2 C6DF=E[ 96 3642>6 2>@?8 E9@D6 =:DE65 2D “=@DE 2E D62]” w:D H2C =2DE65 gc 52JD] #6DE :? A6246[ yv — H6 C6>6>36C]k^Am

k9bmtA:=@8F6k^9bm

kAm!C6D:56?E uC2?<=:? s] #@@D6G6=E E@@< D6G6C2= 4CF:D6D 23@2C5 w@FDE@? :? E96 `hb_D] xE :D D2:5 E92E E9:D D9:A H2D 9:D 72G@C:E6]k^Am